Rajnath Singh Says ‘Sindh May Return to India’, Recalls L K Advani’s Words on Civilisational Ties
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh sparked a major political and cultural discussion after stating that “borders can change” and that Sindh could return to India in the future, while addressing an event hosted by the Sindhi community. His remarks revisited the long-standing civilisational connection between India and Sindh, a region that became part of Pakistan after the 1947 Partition.
Speaking in Mumbai, Singh referenced BJP veteran L K Advani, recalling how the former Deputy Prime Minister had often said that Sindhi Hindus of his generation never accepted the separation of Sindh from India. Advani, born in Karachi in 1927, had described India as “incomplete without Sindh.”
Civilisation Beyond Borders, Says Rajnath Singh
Rajnath Singh highlighted that many ancient civilisations have disappeared, but Indian civilisation endures. He compared Sindh’s cultural heritage with references to Greece, Egypt and Rome, which faded from prominence over centuries.
He emphasised that Bharat represents an immortal civilisation, and Sindh remains connected to it culturally, regardless of political borders. Singh noted how both Hindus and many Muslims in Sindh have historically considered the Indus River (Sindhu) sacred.
He added that the mention of Sindh in India’s national anthem reflects this cultural continuity and identity that extends beyond geography.
Sindh After Partition
Sindh became part of Pakistan after the Partition, with a major stretch of the Indus River also lying across the border. Despite this political separation, Singh said the cultural and emotional significance of Sindh has not reduced for Indians, especially the Sindhi community displaced during Partition.
He said the identity of Sindh remains tied to India’s civilisational roots, and its cultural relevance remains unchanged.
Advani’s Earlier Reflections
L K Advani, who turned 98 this month, had previously expressed sorrow that his birthplace was no longer part of India. In a 2017 event, he said he believed India felt “incomplete without Sindh.”
Rajnath Singh’s remarks echo those sentiments and have added renewed focus to cultural narratives surrounding Partition, belonging and heritage.
Political and Public Reactions
The comments have triggered discussions across:
● political circles
● historians and cultural scholars
● social media users
● Sindhi community groups
Some view the statement as symbolic and cultural, others see geopolitical undertones, while many interpret it as a tribute to the Sindhi community’s heritage and resilience.
Why the Remarks Matter Now
The remarks come at a time when:
● cultural identity politics is prominent
● historical narratives shape political messaging
● global borders and conflicts are widely debated
● diaspora communities seek renewed recognition
The reference to shifting borders, paired with civilisational continuity, adds weight to public interpretation and media attention.
Final Thoughts from TheTrendingPeople.com
Rajnath Singh’s remarks highlight how history, memory and identity continue to shape national conversations long after the Partition. The connection between Sindh and India reflects emotional heritage as much as cultural continuity. As political narratives evolve, the idea of belonging remains central to how communities remember their past and imagine their future.